The Lac-Mégantic oil train catastrophe eight years later: Justice still denied

Forty-seven people died that night—their hopes and dreams obliterated, future wiped out.

July 6, 2021

3-minute read

Content warning: This article mentions train accidents, death, suicide, and PTSD. 

On July 6, 2013, a runaway train loaded with highly volatile Bakken shale oil bound for the Irving refinery in St. John New Brunswick derailed and exploded in town of Lac-Mégantic, nestled in the southeast corner of Québec.

It was the worst industrial disaster on Canadian soil in over a century.

Eight years after this terrible tragedy, the wounds are still raw. Ongoing environmental, physical and post-traumatic health issues afflict members of the community.

The citizens of Lac-Mégantic have still not been accorded the justice they seek and deserve.

To mark the anniversary, a demonstration is being held near the curve where the fateful train derailed. The organizers, The Lac-Mégantic Coalition for Rail Safety, are demanding an independent inquiry, which still has not been held, and a permanent moratorium preventing oil trains from passing through the town.

Conservative and Liberal governments repeatedly refused to hold a commission of inquiry. Neither Transport Canada nor the railways wanted uncomfortable details of their operations, oversight and accountability to come to light. No politicians, senior government officials or industry executives have been held to account.

Parliamentary investigations into the Lac-Mégantic disaster, under majority governments, were given limited mandates.

The Transportation Safety Board (TSB) investigation and that of the auditor general were limited in scope. Moreover, the TSB investigation left many unanswered questions.

Subsequent civil and criminal proceedings were settled behind closed doors, with the exception of the criminal negligence trial against three front-line workers. And in that trial, no government, industry, nor company decision-maker was called to testify.

The citizens of Lac-Mégantic deserve to know the truth about what happened, why it happened, and who was responsible. The relationship between a powerful industry—which, in effect, regulates itself—and an under-resourced and deferential Transport Canada resulted in multiple regulatory failures that contributed to the disaster. They need to be brought to light. I have written extensively about the capture-complicity relationship between the regulator and the regulated industry.

Although an inquiry cannot bring criminal or civil indictments, it can compel witnesses to testify under oath and be cross-examined; it can make a determination of misconduct and assign blame against individuals or organizations.

Importantly, an inquiry provides an opportunity for those who were affected to tell their stories for the record and to help heal their wounds.

Finally, an inquiry can make recommendations to improve the rail safety regime, to help prevent the recurrence of another Lac-Mégantic.

The citizens of Lac-Mégantic have still not been accorded the justice they seek and deserve.

The long-promised rail bypass around the town still has not begun construction

The rebuilt curve where the fateful train derailed is more dangerous than the original, and trains carrying dangerous goods continue to pass through day and night.

CP Rail, which recently bought the rail line that passes through Lac-Mégantic, has been put in charge of the planning, specifications and construction of the 12 km bypass. Paid for entirely by the Canadian [60%] and Québec governments [40%], including the acquisition of properties that the route traverses, CP will take ownership of the bypass once completed.

The federal government has repeatedly committed to construction beginning a year from now, and the deadline for completion of the bypass by the 2023, the tenth anniversary of the tragedy. However, in a letter to the transport minister, the CEO of CP Rail, Keith Creel, stated that this deadline was unrealistic. Apparently, CP, which still hasn’t completed its feasibility evaluation of the route—is in control of the timeline for a bypass that the community has been awaiting for far too long and which it will own, gratis.

CP Rail continues to deny any accountability for its role in the disaster

To add insult to injury, CP Rail is still in court seeking to evade its responsibility to contribute to the class action fund for victims, as well as clean-up costs incurred by the Québec government.

Moreover, it has managed, on a technicality, to squirm out of the wrongful death suit filed in U.S. court. According to victims’ lawyers, CP has escaped liability after having covered up which of its U.S. subsidiaries was responsible—namely, the obscure Soo Line based in Minneapolis. By using the plaintiffs’ failure to name the correct subsidiary initially, CP convinced the court to throw out the case. According to the plaintiff’s attorney. CPPacific has a long history of using its “obscure web of corporate affiliates” to get out of trouble.

CP’s pernicious behaviour should come as no surprise. Former CEO Hunter Harrison pioneered the cost-cutting operating model known as Precision Scheduled Railroading. Its main axiom: Company profits and shareholder value above all. Current CEO Keith Creel is Mr. Harrison’s best-known protégé.

CP Rail is a textbook example of UBC law professor Joel Bakan’s depiction of the fundamental character of the corporation in his book The Corporation and its sequel The New Corporation— “the pathological pursuit of profit and power.”

CP Rail is a textbook example of UBC law professor Joel Bakan’s depiction of the fundamental character of the corporation in his book The Corporation and its sequel The New Corporation— “the pathological pursuit of profit and power.”

As I wrote in my book on the disaster: Forty-seven people died that night—their hopes and dreams obliterated, future wiped out. Two more victims followed in suicide. Twenty-seven children lost their parents. Families lost their sons, daughters, mothers, fathers, brothers, sisters, cousins, aunts, uncles. Others lost their friends, lovers, fellow workers, classmates, teammates.

Their deaths were collateral damage from the culmination of government and corporate decisions stretching back almost four decades. Mutually reinforcing policies of deregulation, privatization and fiscal austerity; power relationships that subordinated government’s obligation to protect its citizens from the private interest of corporations.

Decisions that were driven by greed, corruption and hubris—all aligned that terrible night.

The citizens of Lac-Mégantic have waited too long. Justice delayed is justice denied. The time is now to render them justice.

Topics addressed in this article

Share this page

Show your support

Since the beginning of the pandemic, our writers and researchers have provided groundbreaking commentary and analysis that has shaped Canada's response to COVID-19. We've fought for better supports for workers affected by pandemic closures, safer working conditions on the frontline, and more. With the launch of the new Monitor site, we're working harder than ever to share even more progressive news, views and ideas for Canada's road to recovery. Help us grow.

Support the Monitor